Published: September 2025

Last updated: September 2025

Investigating Input Correlation in Probabilistic Sensitivity Analysis

OBJECTIVES: Probabilistic sensitivity analysis (PSA) is used to characterise uncertainty in cost-effectiveness models. A model was developed using R and Shiny to explore the impact of different parameter correlation structures on PSA outputs.

METHODS: A Markov model was built in R to compare a hypothetical treatment and comparator. Three options were built into the model: no correlation (inputs varied independently); part correlation (correlation within but not between costs, utilities and transition matrices); and full correlation (correlation between all inputs). A Shiny interface allowed users to explore the impact of the correlation options with different model parameters. Features of the Shiny model included preloading base case results, running the Markov model with an arbitrary number of health states and costs, and displaying results for different subsets of correlation options. A scenario analysis was included in the Shiny model to determine the circumstances in which correlation had the largest impact by varying the treatment cost as a proxy for the ICER.

RESULTS: While the ICER was comparable across all correlation options, the likelihood of cost-effectiveness differed substantially from 61% to 93%. In all scenarios, the ‘no correlation’ option displayed the most certain likelihood (closest to either 0 or 1) of cost-effectiveness, while the least certain was produced by the full correlation option. Counterintuitively, correlating inputs increased uncertainty because it allowed for a greater number of ‘extreme’ scenarios to be generated, whereas allowing independent generation of large numbers of inputs tends to lead to a ‘cancelling out’ effect. This effect was most pronounced when the ICER is moderately close to the willingness-to-pay threshold.

CONCLUSION: This analysis demonstrates that input correlation can have a substantial impact on the level of certainty in model outputs, and by ignoring this, the model may be over- or under-stating the true level of confidence.

You may also be interested in

Peer-reviewed publication

The Economic and Clinical Impact of an AI-Assisted Tool for Colonoscopy to Support Diagnosis of Colorectal Cancer in Symptomatic Patients in England

YHEC authors: Luc Curtis-Gretton, Angel Varghese, Karina Watts, Hayden Holmes
Publication date: November 2026
Publishers: Springer Nature Link
Journal: BMC Digital Health

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Colorectal cancer (CRC) remains a leading cause of cancer-related mortality in the UK. Early detection and removal of adenomatous polyps are essential to improving outcomes. Artificial intelligence-assisted colonoscopy tools,...

Peer-reviewed publication

Cost-Effectiveness of Transcatheter Aortic Valve Implantation for Asymptomatic Severe Aortic Stenosis in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

YHEC authors: Madison Montgomery, Heather Davies, Lucy Hillcoat
Publication date: October 2026
Journal: Frontiers in Cardiovascular Medicine

Abstract

INTRODUCTION: Aortic stenosis (AS) is defined as the narrowing of the aortic valve. The benefits of implementing early aortic valve replacement (AVR), while the AS is asymptomatic, have been demonstrated...

Peer-reviewed publication

What is the Role of Multidisciplinary Methods to Support Environmental Sustainability in Health Technology Assessment?

YHEC authors: Melissa Pegg, Emma Bishop, Karina Watts
Publication date: October 2026
Publishers: HTAi
Journal: International Journal of Technology Assessment in Healthcare

Abstract

Healthcare contributes up to 8.5 percent of global carbon emissions, amongst other environmental impacts including intensive water consumption, plastics in our environment and pharmaceutical associated pollution. Healthcare supply chains are...